Not All Kitchens Are Improved by Islands!

Kitchen islands are one of the most desired features in modern kitchens. The large islands you see today — often 36 to 48 inches deep — combine cooking, prep space, and seating for the whole family. Some even include a sink or a stove.

In a cascading (or waterfall) island, the countertop material continues on from the edge of the island to cover the sides. They are beautiful.

But not every kitchen can accommodate one.

In fact, in many homes, trying to force a large kitchen island into the space creates more problems than it solves.

Older Homes Were Designed Differently

From time to time a client reaches out to me for a floor plan evaluation after purchasing an older home. It might be a farmhouse or a Victorian house they fell in love with.

They adore the character of the home — but they can’t stand the kitchen.

That’s because many older kitchens were built with the opposite of today’s open concept in mind. Cooking was once a secluded activity. Either the mother of the household or a household servant would prepare elaborate meals from scratch and preferred to be tucked away from the rest of the home.

As a result, these kitchens were designed purely for cooking, not for eating or socializing.

There were exceptions. Some farmhouses had enough space for a full-size work table where meals could be shared. In those kitchens, adding an island can sometimes work.

But in most older homes, a full-size kitchen island simply doesn’t fit.

The Storage Trade-Off

When you install a large island that is three feet deep or more in a small kitchen, something has to give.

Often it means you can no longer install cabinets along one wall of the kitchen. While the open feeling might make cooking more enjoyable, you lose a significant amount of convenient storage.

Yes, you can add storage inside the island itself. But island storage usually requires bending down or squatting to reach it. It’s not nearly as accessible as upper cabinets or a pantry.

For someone who is young, nimble, and doesn’t need much storage, this may not be a problem.

That wall could even become something fun — a place for art, family photos, a chalkboard calendar, or even a television to make cooking time more enjoyable.

But for many households, kitchen storage matters.

The Problem With Oversized Islands

Some islands go overboard in depth — more than four feet wide.

At that point, cleaning the center becomes a challenge. A smaller person may practically have to glide across the counter just to reach the middle.

Asking for the salt across the kitchen island goes, from being a favor, to becoming a logistical challenge that demands a precise slide over marble, or a dangerous toss. That, or someone has to get up and walk to the other side to deliver the salt shaker.

When an island becomes impractical to use, it stops being good design — no matter how stylish it looks.

A Kitchen Island That Was Never Meant to Be

I once worked with a client who dreamed of having a large cascading kitchen island in the small kitchen of her old home.

Unfortunately, the house simply couldn’t support it. The size of the kitchen and the construction of the home made it impractical.

The interior designer was making increasingly awkward design compromises just to squeeze the island into the space — things that would have bothered her forever and made guests wonder what had happened to the room.

I couldn’t approve the design.

Instead, I suggested a long and narrow kitchen island cart.

But she didn’t want to hear it. At that time, island carts were not yet popular, and the idea didn’t match the kitchen she had imagined. Eventually she fired me because I wouldn’t approve the plan.

A Solution That Works: The Long, Narrow Island Cart

In many kitchens, the better solution is the long, narrow kitchen island cart.

This approach gives you the functionality of an island — a place for food prep and conversation where two or three people can comfortably gather.

But it also preserves the cabinetry and storage along the kitchen walls.

Another benefit is that it keeps eating out of the kitchen itself, which is generally the preferred arrangement in Feng Shui.

Why Eating at a Kitchen Island Isn’t Ideal

In Feng Shui, the best way to eat is at a standard dining table that is about 28 to 30 inches high.

High stools around a kitchen island may feel casual and modern, but they place unnecessary strain on the ankles, knees, hips, and lower back. When people are young they may not notice the effect, but over time the body certainly does.

There’s also a social aspect.

High stools encourage quick, rushed meals. People perch rather than settle. Meals become more like transactions than shared moments.

A proper table encourages people to sit comfortably, stay longer, and actually enjoy one another’s company.

When the Better Idea Wins

Not long afterward, I had another client with a very similar house.

She was open to the idea of the long, narrow island cart.

It worked beautifully.

Because the cart was far less expensive than building a massive island, she was able to invest the savings in higher-quality cabinetry and countertops.

And then something interesting happened.

About a year later, long kitchen island carts started appearing everywhere. What had once seemed unconventional suddenly became fashionable.

In the end she had a kitchen that worked beautifully for her daily life — and one that impressed her friends as well.

Good Design Is About Fit, Not Trends

Trends come and go, but good design is about creating a space that fits the home, the people who live in it, and the way the room is actually used.

Sometimes the most beautiful kitchen isn’t the one that follows the latest fashion.

It’s the one that respects the house — and supports the life that unfolds inside it.

My Kitchen

My kitchen is one of those kitchens that would not fit an island. The challenge of having such a small space for cooking and food preparation, has forced me to design it very efficiently. I wrote an article about this on Substack. Enjoy it here:

https://fengshuiforus.substack.com/p/the-perfectly-placed-trash-can

And to read a fun story about how I ended up doing our own kitchen backsplash years ago, go here:

https://fengshuiforus.substack.com/p/the-backsplash-the-pressure-cooker

Want to start learning Feng Shui? Take the class Feng Shui Explained.

Share with Us!

💖 What did you love most about this article?
🌟 What was the most valuable thing you learned?
🌸 How will you apply this in your life?

Scroll down to the bottom of this page and let us know your thoughts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.